WE ARE NOW LOCATED AT 5775 BROADWAY ST LANCASTER, NY 14086
Business hours: Monday through Friday
9am - 4pm
716-683-2130

About us

By offering world class protection for your Auto, Home, Rental property, Motorcycle, RV, Boat, Golf Cart, and Small Business we make sure that you're covered today as well as in the future so that you can focus on what is important to you and your family. At Nickel City Insurance our #1 job is to assist you in identifying your needs and problems, while putting together a customized plan that's simple and easy to understand.

-Nickel City Insurance Agency, Inc.

Founded in June of 2000

Having been a leader in providing quality protection for thousands of individuals, families and businesses throughout our state. Providing superior customer service and low rates along with our ability to understand our customer’s coverage needs drives the success of our agency.

Meet our people

Paul N Justinger

Agency Owner and Pricipal Agent

Paul's experience and dedication to the insurances industry for the last 23 years has provided him with a deep understanding of how to tailer solutions to meet individual insurance needs. By providing personalized service and clear communication, he has proven to create a positive impact and a strong reputation within the community.

Mary Pych

Internal Processing Manager

Mary came to us with a lifetime of experiance in the costomer service field. We have been lucky to have Mary with us for the past 8 years helping our clients in the best way possible. If you need help with billing or changing something on your policy, Mary is the best at helping you!

Tony Schiraldi

Independent Agent

Tony has been an Agent at Nickel City insurance for over 10 years. With the expertise and knowledge he has obtained in the last decade, he has become an extremly valuble asset to our team and extremly proficient at finding the coverage that is best for you.

Services

AUTO INSURANCE

Navigating the complexities of auto insurance in a bustling state like New York can be challenging. A skilled broker at Nickel City Insurance acts as your personal guide, helping you find the best coverage. They understand the nuances of various policies and can tailor solutions to fit your specific needs and budget. With their expertise, you can feel confident you're making informed decisions about protecting your vehicle. Having a dedicated broker simplifies the process, offering peace of mind on the busy roads.

Homeowners insurance

Residential properties typically represent the most significant asset for most individuals. We offer comprehensive insurance solutions designed to address your concerns and potential unforeseen circumstances. Please contact us to discuss your specific needs and determine the optimal coverage for you and your family.

motorcycle insurance

Writing motorcycle insurance is always a special treat to our owner Paul. He is both an avid rider and collector of Motorcyles. Be sure to speak to him about your machine. Whether its a Harley Davidson, a Vespa scooter, ATV or even Golf Cart, he will be sure to understand your needs and provide you with the best coverage for your 2, 3 or 4 wheeled machines.

rv insurance

Protecting your valuable RV is a smart decision for peace of mind on the open road. Our comprehensive coverage options are designed to safeguard your investment and your adventures. We offer flexible plans to fit your specific needs and budget, ensuring you have the right level of protection. Our experienced team is dedicated to providing exceptional customer service and support. Enjoy your travels knowing you're covered with our reliable RV insurance.

landlord insurance

Managing a property can be challenging, but finding the right tools shouldn't be. We offer a range of solutions to simplify your responsibilities and maximize your investment. Our products are designed to meet the specific needs of property owners, whether it is long-term or short-term rentals. We understand the importants of covering your asset and ensuring smooth operations. Let us help you find the perfect fit for your unique situation.

boat and yacht insurance

Our boat and yacht insurance provides comprehensive coverage for a range of potential risks. We offer competitive rates and flexible payment options to suit various budgets. Our experienced team understands the unique needs of boat owners. We can tailor policies to provide the specific protection you require, including coverage for physical damage, liability, and even on-water towing. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help safeguard your investment.

umbrella insurance

An umbrella policy offers an extra layer of liability protection beyond your existing insurance policies. It can help cover costs like legal fees and medical expenses if you're held responsible for an accident. This added protection can safeguard your assets and future earnings. Umbrella policies are typically affordable and offer significant peace of mind. Consider an umbrella policy to enhance your financial security.

Nickel City Insurance Agency, Inc.

Call us : 716-683-2130

In a market where auto insurance costs are continually rising, we are all looking for ways to lower our premiums. By taking a New York State Defensive Driver Course you can potentially lower your premium for the next 3 years. Click the underlined link to take you to an online acredited course.

Billing & Payments

We are always happy to take a payment from you during our business hours, but if for some reason you miss us and need to make your payment immediatley, below are a list of numbers you can call to pay directly to your written company.

Travelers: (800) 252-4633

National General: (800) 924-0273

Erie Insurance: (800) 333-0823

A Central: (866) 222-2242

Chautqua Patrons: (716) 664-5823

Sterling Insurance: (800) 462-4661

NY Central Mutual: (800) 355-1717

Merchants: (800) 462-1077

Claims

What to do if you have a claim

Protect your auto and any other property from further damage. Promptly call the police if someone is injured, the damage is extensive, your vehicle has been stolen, or if you need assistance. Never admit liability (fault) or sign a statement unless authorized by us. Always do your best to report the claim to our office so we can properly advise you.We are always on call, so you can reach us anytime day or night. If you would rather report the claim directly to your carrier, below is a list of numbers to our represented companies.